A recent senior prank at the prestigious Collegiate School in Manhattan has caused serious backlash from parents, teachers, and the wider community. Known for its high tuition fees—up to $65,900 per year—Collegiate is one of the most elite all-boys schools in the U.S. But this prank has raised questions about the values the school promotes and the behavior it tolerates.
What Happened During the Prank?
The prank took place on the school’s “Senior Prank Day,” which was supposed to be fun and harmless. Instead, some seniors turned it into a mock border patrol scenario. They set up a fake immigration checkpoint in the school’s main lobby and asked younger students to show fake papers. Some were even tied up with zip ties as part of the act.
But the prank didn’t stop there. It included inappropriate content like fake drugs and images of a former staff member in a disrespectful way. The prank quickly drew strong criticism from many people. Teachers and parents called the act “racist,” “xenophobic,” and “misogynistic,” saying it was hurtful and offensive, especially to Latino students.
How the School Responded
Andrew Prince, the Head of Upper School, responded by canceling several events that were planned to celebrate the seniors. In an email to the staff, he said that the prank had caused “real harm” and that the school was talking to the students involved. He added that apologies might be made, and efforts to repair the damage were being discussed. Prince also said he hoped to still end the school year on a good note for students who had no part in the prank.
The school’s head, Bodie Brizendine, also sent an email to parents and staff expressing regret about how the prank turned out. So far, there has been no official public statement, but many inside the school are asking for stronger action against the 15 seniors believed to have led the incident.
Why This Prank Was a Serious Problem
The prank was meant to have a “Fourth of July” theme, but it ended up targeting race, gender, and immigration in a harmful way. Some of the elements, like hiring a mariachi band, made it feel like a joke at the expense of Latino students. One parent called the event “humiliating,” while some teachers said the school’s “brotherhood” culture may have made students feel like they could act without consequences.
What Happens Next?
Many are now waiting to see what the school does to prevent something like this from happening again. Some teachers are pushing for stronger action to hold the pranksters accountable. The school community, including past students like JFK Jr. and actor David Duchovny, is reflecting on whether the values they once learned are still being taught today.
This incident shows that jokes can go too far and that actions meant to be funny can actually cause pain and offense. It’s a reminder for schools to talk more about respect, kindness, and understanding others. As the Collegiate School deals with the fallout, it also has a chance to teach its students what truly matters—not just being smart, but being responsible and caring too.
